Federal Judge Rules Maine School Committee Discriminated Against Pines Church Over Lease
A federal judge ruled on November 13 that the Hermon School Committee in Maine violated the First Amendment by denying Pines Church a long-term lease for school space. The court found that three committee members showed religious bias during deliberations. The church was awarded $1 in nominal damages plus legal fees.
A federal judge ruled on November 13, 2026, that the Hermon School Committee in Maine discriminated against Pines Church by refusing to grant the evangelical congregation a 12-month lease for school facilities.
U.S. District Court Judge Lance E. Walker issued a 37-page decision finding that the committee violated the First Amendment and the Maine Human Rights Act. The church had applied to rent Hermon High School for Sunday services on an annual lease. The committee rejected that request and offered only a month-to-month arrangement instead.
Judge Walker concluded that the religious identity of Pines Church was a "substantial factor" in the committee's decision. He identified three members, Stephanie Oiler, Christopher McLaughlin, and Karen Shorey, as having shown "bad motives" during the process.
The ruling singled out McLaughlin for asking "intrusive" questions about the church's denomination and its positions on abortion, LGBTQ+ issues, and diversity, equity, and inclusion. The court found that concerns raised by Oiler about sanitation and janitorial requirements were "pretextual" and served as cover for bias against the church.
Walker wrote that novelty is not a legal basis to discriminate against a religious organization. When public school facilities are opened to community groups, the government cannot exclude religious organizations based on their faith.
Despite finding constitutional violations, the judge did not overturn the committee's 4-1 vote on the lease terms. Pines Church and its pastor, Matt Gioia, were awarded $1 in nominal damages. The school district must also pay the church's attorney's fees and litigation costs.
Advocates for Faith and Freedom, which represented the church, called the ruling a win for religious liberty in public spaces.


